Was brutus justified in killing caesar
I n january of 49 bc, julius caesar led his army across the rubicon river in northern italy (see caesar crosses the rubicon, 49 bc) and plunged the roman republic into civil warcaesar's rival, pompey, fled to greece within three months caesar controlled the entire italian peninsula and in spain had defeated the legions loyal to pompey. Although he did show signs of hubris, or excessive pride, caesar’s assassination by the conspirators was not justified because their reasons were based on theories and biased opinions, caesar was a good man, and his murder was committed for the good of the people killing him and not for the good of rome. In the tragedy of julius caesar, after the death of caesar both brutus and antony spoke at caesar's funeral brutus finished his speech trying to convince the crowd that they did the right thing to kill caesar because he was ambitious. Decimus junius brutus albinus (decimus) was a great general and a close friend of caesar’s who rose in the ranks to become one of the most powerful men in rome. They might’ve been justified thinking on the principle of defending the republic, but they were not right, thinking of what caesar could accomplish if he lived, say, another 20–30 years caesar was a military genius, very good politician , a talented orator and quite skilled at knowing human nature.
I think caesar killer weren't justified because caesar did everything to help romebrutus was his closest adviser and it wasn't fair that even he tried to kill caesarcaesar was really a effective leader in rome and it wasn't fairit was like he was getting killed for doing something good for the country. Which reason does brutus give to justify killing caesar brutus thinks caesar is a tyrant who will only become more of a tyrant if he gains power brutus himself wants to become king of rome brutus thinks that caesar is trying to kill him, so brutus must act first. Pertaining to caesar, i believe brutus had justifiable motive to kill caesar, and the homicide, similar to the murder of osama bin laden was committed to stop a tyrant from gaining more power had brutus let caesar live, he would’ve become a sovereign and all hell would’ve broke loose.
Brutus was justified for assassinating caesar as he eliminated potential problems that could have arisen with caesar taking the crown before the issues became too large to handle this rationale was considered by brutus when he first contemplated whether or not he should join the conspiracy. Brutus was convinced by cassius (both close to caesar in rank), that caesar was power-hungery and bad for rome brutus was naive enough to listen to the scheming cassius the only thing brutus did wrong, was be human. Preserving freedom in rome is a just cause, certainly, but are brutus and the others justified in killing caesar for what he may do if he is crowned is the disturbing fate of flavius and marullus, as mentioned in a previous scene, enough evidence that caesar would be a tyrant, if crowned. One of the questions that are frequently asked is was brutus justified to kill caesar the stance of this essay is con, and there are three major reasons brutus's reasons to kill caesar, brutus and caesar's relationship, and lastly, no human being is justified to kill another 1st point brutus' reasons to kill caesar were too fragile that it. Brutus was the son of caesar’s mistress servilia (some mistakenly believed he was caesar’s son) and married to the roman orator cato’s daughter portia marcus porcius cato (or cato the younger), a strong supporter of pompey and outspoken critic of caesar, had committed suicide in 46 bce while in north africa.
We are further informed that there are many among us who think they are justified in believing that the assassination of julius caesar was a put- up thing--a cut-and-dried arrangement, hatched by marcus brutus and a lot of his hired roughs, and carried out only too faithfully according to the program. Julius caesar essay prompt _____ 5 points - wednesday, april 2, 2014: the three point thesis of the five paragraph essay is due bring a printed copy to class in 12 point times new roman font. When: caesar was born in 100 bc, and assassinated on the ides of march, 44 bc why: caesar was assassinated by the conspirators because he was becoming too powerful and was taking their power away from them how: the conspirators planned the assassination, and stabbed caesar 33 times caesar refuses. Marcus brutus: the tragic hero in the tragedy of julius caesar essay - in shakespeare’s play the tragedy of julius caesar, the title leads the mind to believe that caesar is the tragic hero however, this is not the case. Stop caesar is by killing him contributing to the idea that brutus thinks he is saving rome he believes that over time, caesar would be the destruction of rome one might suggest that brutus was justified in the murder of caesar, but nobody can argue the fact that brutus betrayed his closest friend with good intentions but bad execution, the.
Was brutus justified in killing caesar
Although brutus killed julius caesar for the right reason, it is still unjustified to kill an innocent man for what he had not done political assassination is justified depending on the circumstances. Justification of brutus’ betrayal of william shakespeare´s julius caesar 2006 words 9 pages in william shakespeare’s tragedy julius caesar, the character of marcus brutus is tasked with making a difficult choice: either kill one of his most beloved friends, or risk the corruption and downfall of rome. Julius caesar is a play about political power and how it may be legitimately and illegitimately wielded it also shows the role of what we now call public opinion, which in this play is embodied in the gut responses of the common folk.
Brutus is justified in killing caesar because he did it to help save rome brutus believed, think him as a serpent's egg, which, hatched, would, as his kind, grow mischievous, and kill him in the shell (iii33-36. The murder of julius caesar by brutus was not justified considering the empire was flourishing under his rule, he was a brilliant commander, and he had a strong connection with the local people under the rule of caesar, the roman empire thrived. When brutus went into the capital after he assassinated caesar he stood up in front of the angry people of rome and justified his actions “ if then that friend demanded why brutus rose against caesar, this is my answer: not that i loved caesar less, but that i loved rome more” (p128, lines 19-21) here, brutus is saying that killing. It's not that brutus didn't willingly kill caesar he's as committed to his own death now as he was to caesar's then brutus commits an act of self-sacrifice with no pride or self-pity.
Despite cassius' efforts at persuading brutus to join his cause, brutus is already thinking of killing caesar this could be clearly brought out by the time when brutus happens to be the first to state that caesar should be killed (shakespeare 23. Conspiracy in doing so, he recruits brutus, a beloved politician whose primary concern is the well-being of the citizens he does this by convincing brutus that the murder is in the citizens’ this political ambition of his is never justified in the play his reasons for killing caesar he also wanted to kill caesar’s friend and. I believe that he was at that time, julius caesar presented the greatest threat to the republic yes, this created a power vacuum which led to the empire, but brutus was definitely justified in killing caesar.